6 Things I Always Look for at the Thrift Store (Every Single Time!)

There’s nothing quite like the thrill of a good thrift store find! Whether I have something specific in mind or I’m just browsing the aisles, I always keep a mental checklist of things I always look for at the thrift store.

Over the years, I’ve learned which items are worth scooping up and which ones to leave behind. From charming vintage linens to sturdy, solid wood furniture, these treasures help me create a cozy, old-fashioned home filled with charm and character.

There’s something magical about walking into a thrift store not knowing what treasures you’ll find. Whether I’m just browsing or on a mission for something specific, I have a handful of go-to items I always keep an eye out for.

Thrift store shelves with eclectic mix of decor: clocks, plates, vases, and glassware. Rustic and homey tone with a vintage aesthetic.Thrift store shelves with eclectic mix of decor: clocks, plates, vases, and glassware. Rustic and homey tone with a vintage aesthetic.

Table Of Contents

There’s nothing quite like the thrill of a good thrift store find! Whether I have something specific in mind or I’m just browsing the aisles, I always keep a mental checklist of things I always look for at the thrift store.
Thrifting for Beginners: 3 Helpful Tips to Score the Best Finds
1. Go Often and Be Patient
2. Keep a Running Wish List
3. Inspect Items Carefully
What to Avoid When Thrifting: Red Flags to Watch For
Here are 6 things I always look for at the thrift store—and why I love them!
Quick Tips on Cleaning Thrifted Items
Frequently Asked Questions
More Posts You’ll Fancy
Final thoughts…
Love Vintage Style?

Thrifting for Beginners: 3 Helpful Tips to Score the Best Finds

If you’re new to thrifting, it can feel a little overwhelming at first—but trust me, it’s so worth it once you get the hang of it! Here are three simple tips to help you get started and make the most out of your next thrift store visit:

1. Go Often and Be Patient

Thrift stores are constantly rotating inventory, so it pays to pop in regularly. Some days you might leave empty-handed, and other days you’ll hit the jackpot.

The key is patience and consistency—check back often and give yourself time to really browse.

2. Keep a Running Wish List

Before you go thrifting, jot down a few things you’re on the lookout for—whether it’s vintage linens, old books, or solid wood furniture.

Having a list keeps you focused and helps you avoid impulse buys that don’t fit your home or style.

3. Inspect Items Carefully

Always examine your finds for damage, missing parts, or musty odors—especially when shopping for fabric items like linens or upholstered furniture.

A little wear can be charming, but you’ll want to avoid anything that’s too far gone unless you’re confident you can clean or restore it.

What to Avoid When Thrifting: Red Flags to Watch For

When in doubt, inspect closely and trust your instincts—there’s always another great find just around the corner! While thrifting is a treasure hunt, not everything is worth bringing home. Here are a few things I typically pass on:

Particle Board Furniture: These pieces may look nice at first glance, but they often don’t hold up over time and can be tricky to repair or refinish.
Cracked or Chipped Mason Jars & Crocks: These can be unsafe for food storage and may continue to deteriorate. Always inspect glassware and pottery carefully.
Heavily Stained or Musty Linens: A light stain can sometimes be cleaned, but deep-set discoloration or strong odors might not come out—even with a good soak.
Items with Mold or Mildew: If you spot mold (especially on books or fabric), it’s best to walk away. Mold can be difficult to remove and may pose health risks.
Broken Electronics or Lamps: Unless you’re confident in your repair skills, it’s safer to avoid items that don’t work or have exposed wiring.

Glassware display on a store shelf: a large Mason jar, ornate glass cups, and a blue floral mug, creating a quaint and vintage atmosphere.

Here are 6 things I always look for at the thrift store—and why I love them!

Crocks & Mason Jars

I have a soft spot for old crockery and vintage mason jars. These timeless pieces are not only functional but also incredibly stylish.
I use them in my kitchen for storing utensils, displaying flowers, or organizing pantry staples.
Pro Tip: Check the bottom of the jars or crocks for identifying marks or stamps—some can be worth more than you think!

Old Books

I can never resist thumbing through a shelf of old books. Whether it’s a weathered cookbook, a charming children’s story, or a classic novel, old books make beautiful decor—and are often a great read, too.
Thrifting Tip: Look for titles with worn covers, interesting spines, or embossed designs. They add warmth and character to any shelf or coffee table display.

Blue & White and Floral Dishes

Whether it’s a delicate teacup, a floral plate, or a classic blue and white transferware piece, I always keep an eye out for charming dishware. These timeless patterns are not only collectible but also look stunning displayed in a hutch, layered on open shelves, or used for special gatherings.
Why I Love Them: They instantly add vintage charm to any space, and even a single plate or bowl can make a beautiful statement in your decor.

Solid Wood Furniture

If I see a solid wood piece at a thrift store (especially at a good price), I stop and give it a good once-over. Quality, real wood furniture is getting harder to come by, and I love the idea of giving a forgotten piece new life.
Whether it’s a small side table or a vintage dresser, I always look for sturdy joints and classic design.
Why It’s Worth It: With a little elbow grease (and maybe a fresh coat of paint or stain), you can turn a thrifted piece into something truly beautiful and long-lasting.

Baskets

Wicker baskets are one of my all-time favorite thrift finds. They’re so versatile and can be used in nearly every room—for organizing, decorating, or just adding texture.
I especially love finding lidded baskets or ones with unique shapes and handles.
Styling Idea: Use baskets to store extra blankets in the living room, keep clutter at bay in your entryway, or hold rolled-up vintage linens on a shelf!

Unique Kitchenware & Utensils

From vintage rolling pins and butter crocks to old enamelware and cast iron pans, I love browsing the kitchen section for hidden gems. These pieces often carry a nostalgic charm and are built to last. Plus, they look beautiful displayed on open shelves or used in food photography.
Why I Love Them: They combine function and beauty—perfect for adding character to everyday cooking or for styling a farmhouse-inspired kitchen.

“Thrifting is more than just shopping, it’s about finding beauty in the forgotten, and giving items a second chance.” ~Dusty

A large woven basket with a handle sits on a wooden table next to a small crock with a wooden lid. The scene is warm and rustic.

Three stacked off-white plates with scalloped edges on a rustic wooden surface, conveying a simple, elegant, and cozy kitchen setting.

Quick Tips on Cleaning Thrifted Items

Bringing home secondhand treasures is exciting, but it’s important to give them a proper clean before putting them to use. Taking the time to clean your thrifted items not only makes them safe to use—it also helps preserve their charm for years to come! Here are a few quick tips to freshen up your finds:

Blue & White and Floral Dishes: Hand wash with warm water and mild dish soap using a soft sponge. Avoid the dishwasher to preserve delicate patterns, especially on vintage or gold-trimmed pieces. For stains, soak in baking soda and water or spot-treat with a little hydrogen peroxide. Always dry thoroughly and inspect for cracks or crazing before food use.
Mason Jars & Crocks: Wash thoroughly with hot soapy water, rinse, and sanitize with a vinegar soak. Inspect for chips or cracks before using for food storage.
Books: Gently wipe covers with a dry microfiber cloth. If musty, try sealing the book in a bag with baking soda for a few days to absorb odors.
Baskets: Dust with a dry brush or vacuum with a brush attachment. For deeper cleaning, wipe with a damp cloth and let air dry completely in the sun.
Unique Kitchenware & Utensils: Wash all items thoroughly with hot, soapy water. For wooden utensils, clean with a damp cloth and mild soap, then treat with food-safe mineral oil to prevent drying out. Avoid soaking wood pieces. For vintage metal tools, gently scrub with baking soda paste to remove rust and rinse well.

A woven basket with a handle holds a blue ceramic dish, a white ceramic bowl, and a glass container with a pink price sticker, set on a wooden table.

Frequently Asked Questions

What day is best to go thrifting?

The best day to go thrifting can vary by store, but many thrift stores restock early in the week, especially on Mondays and Tuesdays after weekend donations. If you’re looking for fresh inventory, try visiting the store right when it opens mid-week. Some shops also offer discount days on specific weekdays, so be sure to ask or check their website for special offers.

How do I clean vintage linens or secondhand items?

For vintage linens, soak them in a gentle detergent with warm water (or even a mixture of baking soda and vinegar for stubborn odors or yellowing). Avoid using bleach, as it can damage delicate fibers. Lay them flat to air dry or line dry when possible. For secondhand items like baskets, jars, or furniture, wipe down with a mixture of mild soap and water or vinegar. Always test a small area first, and ensure items are fully dry before use or storage.

Are thrift stores cheaper than antique shops?

Yes, thrift stores are generally much cheaper than antique shops because they’re often donation-based and price items to sell quickly. Antique stores usually curate and restore their pieces, which adds to the cost. However, the thrill of the thrift is finding that hidden gem for a fraction of the price—especially when it comes to vintage linens, solid wood furniture, or old crocks!

Final thoughts…

Thrifting is more than just shopping—it’s about curating a home that feels personal and lived-in. From mason jars to solid wood furniture, these items aren’t just thrift store scores—they’re stories waiting to be told in your space.

So next time you’re out thrifting, keep your eyes peeled for these treasures. You never know what gem you’ll bring home next! What’s your best thrift find? Tell me in the comments!

Love Vintage Style?

Download my free eBook: Decorating with Thrifted & Antiue Finds! It’s perfect for keeping in your bag on your next thrift trip!

Download Now!

Image of a 10-page eBook titled 'Decorating with Thrifted & Antique Finds' showing a vintage-style desk with decor. Warm, inviting tone.