How to Turn a Pie Cabinet into a Pantry

Sharing is caring!

If you’re looking for a creative and functional way to add kitchen storage, I’ll show you how to turn a pie cabinet into a pantry. It is a simple, stylish solution that fits easily into various decor styles. Pie cabinets, also known as pie safes, feature built-in shelves and an enclosed design, making them ideal for organizing canned goods, baskets, canisters, and other pantry essentials.

Whether your kitchen is decorated in a warm farmhouse style, a cozy cottage design, or a clean, modern aesthetic, a pie cabinet can seamlessly complement your space.

With a little organization and smart storage ideas, you can transform a vintage piece into a practical pantry that adds both charm and convenience to your kitchen.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases, and this post contains affiliate links to products I love ♥ See my full disclaimer here!

Why This Works

• Good shelf spacing – fits canned goods, canisters, and baskets.
• Enclosed design – protects food from dust and pests.
• Compact footprint – ideal for small kitchens or tight spaces.
• Adds charm – brings vintage or farmhouse style to your kitchen.

How to Turn a Pie Cabinet Into a Pantry: Step-by-Step

Step 1: Clean and Prep the Cabinet

Even though the cabinet was in excellent condition, I gave it a quick wipe-down inside and out. Removing dust and refreshing the surfaces helps ensure food items stay clean.

Helpful Tip: Use a mild cleaner or a mix of warm water and vinegar to avoid any harsh chemical smells.

Step 2: Organize Items by Category

A successful pantry starts with good organization. Grouping like items together makes it easier to find what you need and prevents overbuying.

Here’s how we organized ours:

1. Canned goods are lined up on the bottom shelves for stability and weight distribution.
2. Baking canisters are placed at eye level.
3. Baskets for snacks, packets, or small items.
4. Overflow pantry staples are stored on the top shelves.

Helpful Tip: Keep the heaviest items on the lowest shelves to prevent tipping and ensure safe access.

Step 3: Use Containers and Baskets

Containers help maximize your space and keep ingredients fresh. Clear canisters work especially well because you can instantly see what you have. Baskets are great for grouping snacks, baking supplies, or odd-shaped items.

Helpful Tip: Choose containers with airtight seals to keep dry goods fresher for longer.

Step 4: Label Everything

Labeling helps keep your pie cabinet pantry easy to maintain. Whether you choose printed labels or a simple marker and tape, labeling ensures everyone in the household knows where everything belongs.

Helpful Tip: Add a small label inside baskets so you always remember the original category.

Step 5: Style the Top for a Finished Look

While the inside of the pie cabinet is all about functionality, the outside is a chance to add a bit of style. You can keep the top simple with a vase, a small lamp, or a cutting board. A minimal look keeps it clean and prevents clutter.

Additional Tips for Pie Cabinet Pantry Success

• Use shelf liners to protect the wood and prevent sliding.
• Rotate items regularly to keep food fresh.
• Keep frequently used items at eye level for easy access.
• If your cabinet has screened or punched-tin doors, place light-sensitive items in opaque bins.
• Add small, battery-powered lights if the interior is dark.
• Use risers or tiered organizers to make spices and jars easier to see.
• Keep heavier items on the bottom shelves for stability.

Troubleshooting Your Pie Cabinet Pantry

Even the best pie cabinets may need a little adjustment to function perfectly as a pantry. Here are solutions to common issues:

• Musty Smell: If your cabinet smells musty, remove all items and wipe the interior with a warm water and vinegar solution. Leave a small bowl of baking soda inside for 24 hours to absorb lingering odors.
• Narrow Shelves: If your shelves are too narrow for certain items, use baskets or tiered organizers to maximize vertical space. Stackable containers can also help fit more while keeping everything accessible.
• Dark Interiors: Dark cabinets can make it hard to see items. Add battery-powered puck lights or LED strip lights, or use clear containers and labels to improve visibility.
• Humid Climates: In humid areas, avoid storing moisture-sensitive items like flour or grains directly in the cabinet. Use airtight containers or consider adding silica gel packets to help reduce moisture.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

More Posts You’ll Fancy!

Storage Ideas for Small Kitchens

A pie cabinet pantry is especially useful in small kitchens, but making the most of limited space requires a few strategies:

• Use Vertical Space – Stack baskets, canisters, and containers to make the most of every shelf height.
• Store Overflow Items – Keep extra pantry staples, snacks, or less-frequently used items in the pie cabinet to free up space in the main cabinet.
• Keep the Cabinet Accessible – Avoid overloading the top shelves; store everyday items at eye level or slightly lower for easy reach.
• Design Around Limited Counter Space – Place the pie cabinet against an empty wall or corner so it doesn’t crowd your counters, creating extra workspace.

Tip: Consider adding tiered organizers or lazy susans inside the cabinet to maximize space and keep small items visible.

Final thoughts…

Turning a pie cabinet into a pantry is a quick and beautiful way to add extra storage to your kitchen. For just $50, we gained a functional, organized space that blends seamlessly with our home’s style.

To make your pie cabinet truly your own, consider adding personal touches like painting it a color that complements your kitchen, installing decorative wallpaper on the interior for a fun surprise when you open it, or swapping out the hardware for something that reflects your personal taste.

These customizations can enhance the charm and uniqueness of your pantry, allowing it to reflect your creative vision. Whether you’re furnishing a small kitchen or love incorporating vintage pieces, a pie cabinet pantry is a smart, affordable solution.